Which one do you hear?

If there's something on your mind that just doesn't seem to fall into any of the other categories, well, it quite likely belongs inside Joe Finneman's marketplace. Think of it as a general store for general discussions!

Which one do you hear?

Yanny
5
42%
Laurel
4
33%
Both
2
17%
I heard one at first but switched to the other
1
8%
 
Total votes : 12

Which one do you hear?

Postby Petrichor » Wed May 16, 2018 10:26 pm

When you listen to this clip, do you hear "Yanny" or "Laurel"? I'm sure just about everyone has seen (or more accurately, heard) this by now, but I'm curious to find out what everyone hears. I'll leave bookworm to explain the sciency stuff if he so chooses, but if it's been driving you crazy, this tool actually helps you hear both words.

I personally can hear both; Laurel is a little more difficult to catch, but I hear "Yanny" so clearly that I don't understand how anyone could not hear it.

And if this whole thing seems familiar...
Image
Image
I guess I'll stick around
User avatar
Petrichor

The best is yet to come.

 
Posts: 202
Joined: Wed Jul 04, 2012 7:58 am
Age: 23
Gender: Female

Cash on hand: 43.13
Bank: 600.00

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby Bob » Wed May 16, 2018 11:34 pm

In the standard one, I don't hear anything but laurel. Even with the helper tool, I don't hear anything different until it's about two or three steps out from the extreme end, and then it doesn't sound like "Yanny", but Yerry.
-
User avatar
Bob

Loyal

 
Posts: 434
Joined: Wed Sep 27, 2006 2:38 am
Location: Texas
Age: 26
Gender: Male

Cash on hand: 356.38
Bank: 0.00

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby shnoodlec » Thu May 17, 2018 9:40 am

I heard Yanny very clearly at first, but then it slowly switched to Laurel, and now I can only hear Laurel... :-k
Image

High wellborn Lady shnoodlec Knight of the Order of Augustine, formally known as Queen of the Monkeys. now enjoying an era of peace between the Monkeys and Vampires. permanent n00b. Q&A thread HERE. come find me on the ToO chat if you dare.
Why am I even here?
User avatar
shnoodlec

surely it must be madness to hear no voice at all.

 
Posts: 82
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2013 10:30 am
Location: cyberspace
Age: 15

Cash on hand: 105.36
Bank: 0.00

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby Catspaw » Sat May 19, 2018 8:12 pm

I heard Yanny the first time, and then Yuri the second time. I don't want to listen any more because I don't want to hear yet another option! ;)
Image
Care Bear Admin
Care Bear Admin
User avatar
Catspaw

 
Posts: 28241
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 7:42 am
Location: Canada
Age: 33
Gender: Female

Cash on hand: 6,261.25
Bank: 1,958.31

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby shnoodlec » Sat May 19, 2018 9:14 pm

There's a Laurel St. in my city, and someone taped "YANNY ST." under it. :lol:
Image

High wellborn Lady shnoodlec Knight of the Order of Augustine, formally known as Queen of the Monkeys. now enjoying an era of peace between the Monkeys and Vampires. permanent n00b. Q&A thread HERE. come find me on the ToO chat if you dare.
Why am I even here?
User avatar
shnoodlec

surely it must be madness to hear no voice at all.

 
Posts: 82
Joined: Mon Nov 18, 2013 10:30 am
Location: cyberspace
Age: 15

Cash on hand: 105.36
Bank: 0.00

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby Catspaw » Sun May 20, 2018 5:43 pm

Haha, it's crazy how these silly things consume the internet! That's pretty good.
Image
Care Bear Admin
Care Bear Admin
User avatar
Catspaw

 
Posts: 28241
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 7:42 am
Location: Canada
Age: 33
Gender: Female

Cash on hand: 6,261.25
Bank: 1,958.31

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby Parakeet » Mon May 21, 2018 11:11 am

Yanny is what I hear, though I heard Laurel once.

People are taking about it everywhere. It’s kinda hilarious.
Image
Nerd is the Word
Credits:
Signature-Old Brad
Avatar-Kathy0
I guess I'll stick around
User avatar
Parakeet

Fangirling

 
Posts: 271
Joined: Thu Dec 15, 2016 7:00 pm
Location: A galaxy far, far away...
Age: 16
Gender: Female

Cash on hand: 94.30
Bank: 150.00
Blog: View Blog (2)

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby Arkán Dreamwalker » Mon May 21, 2018 1:52 pm

I hear Yanny.
But this thing is just (basically) two words superimposed with one being higher and the other being lower, so you can mostly one focus on one at a time. But check out this witchcraft.
Black Magic
Arkán Dreamwalker♥Sammy Girl
Image
Image
Image
Catspaw knows all
User avatar
Arkán Dreamwalker

The stoic type.

 
Posts: 828
Joined: Tue Oct 02, 2012 9:24 pm
Location: The Destiny Islands
Gender: Male

Cash on hand: 6.90
Bank: 5,037.43
Blog: View Blog (1)

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby The Top Crusader » Wed May 23, 2018 6:04 am

Definitely only hear Yanny.

I keep seeing some Twitter poll being touted that says a slight majority hear "laurel," but nearly everyone I've talked to in person and in topics like this and on other forums I visit about it, Yanny is the run-away winner.

Could Twitter polling not be 100% accurate!?
Hammer Bro
Hammer Bro
User avatar
The Top Crusader

Old... but not obsolete.

 
Posts: 22236
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 1:04 am
Location: A drawbridge over a lava pit with an axe conveniently off to the side
Age: 36
Gender: Male

Cash on hand: 9,999,999,994,415,312.00
Bank: 5,584,680.26
Highscores: 1
Blog: View Blog (1)

Re: Which one do you hear?

Postby bookworm » Wed May 23, 2018 11:37 am

Thanks for posting about this Petrichor, I'd seen headlines mentioning it for a few days but never clicked the articles because none were clear on what it was actually about so I actually hadn't heard about this yet.

So it's like The Dress but an aural phenomenon rather than visual. Fascinating! Though I think the dress photo is more sensational because it's crazy that we can't trust something we're looking right at, while we know it can be pretty easy to hear things wrong especially if it's just from sole audio with no context aids, but this is still really interesting because the two things people hear are so different.

This article explains the science of why different people are hearing different things:
Why you hear “Laurel” or “Yanny” in that viral audio clip
It comes down to how our brains pick up on, and interpret, different frequencies.

The audio version of “the dress” cleaved the internet, and likely your family, your friends, or your office, into two bitterly divided camps on Tuesday: the Laurels and the Yannys.

It began, as it so often does, with a viral clip posted by a high schooler on Reddit, which blew up when Cloe Feldman, a YouTuber and social media influencer, added it to her Instagram story and then to Twitter, asking, “What do you hear?! Yanny or Laurel.” Using that slider tool I start hearing Yanny as soon as it's moved any amount to the right, but in the original audio it's Laurel every time.

That should have settled it, because it’s obviously “Laurel.” But people out there are convinced, for some reason, that this weird robot voice is repeating “Yanny.” (Some people even claim they alternate between hearing “Laurel” and “Yanny,” or, strangest of all, hear both simultaneously. Some people even hear “Geery” or “Garry” or something in between.)

So what’s going on here? The clip is playing around with frequency — and it depends on the range of frequencies listeners hear.

What “Yanny” and “Laurel” have in common

“There’s just enough ambiguity in this fairly low-quality recording that [some] people are hearing it one way and some people are hearing it another,” Brad Story, the associate department head of speech, language, and hearing sciences at Arizona State University, told me.

Humans typically pay attention to three different frequencies when they’re listening to speech. Story said the lowest of the three frequencies is “absolutely essential” for the L’s and R’s — the consonants that make up “Laurel.”

“So when you’re listening to ‘Laurel,’ the reason you get L, R, and L is because of the movement of that third frequency,” he said.

Here’s the catch. The word “Yanny,” the second frequency, has almost exactly the same pattern as the L, R, L in “Laurel,” he added.

One reason for the confusion is the poor quality of the recording. “Typically, if you have a high-quality recording and you’re listening on a good device of some sort, you’re not ever going to be confused by those,” Story said.

So if you’re hearing “Laurel,” you’re likely picking up on the lower frequency. If you hear “Yanny,” you’re picking up on the higher frequency.

It really comes down to how our brains pick up on and interpret these frequencies, Rory Turnbull, a professor of linguistics at the University of Hawaii, said.

Video game developer Dylan Bennett made a video that illustrates what’s going on here.

Turnbull suggested that isolating these frequencies basically homes in on the critical information, making it easier for the brain to pay attention to just “Laurel” or just “Yanny.”

Good news for both “Laurel” and “Yanny” people: the clip is pretty confusing

People might be able to focus on the higher frequencies — the Yannys among us — because they have really great headphones or very good hearing, Benjamin Munson, a professor of speech, language, and hearing sciences at the University of Minnesota, suggested.

“But for the rest of us with po’folk headphones and old-folk hearing, we just hear the lowest-frequency components,” he wrote in an email.

But maybe don’t panic too much about your hearing if you’re on Team Laurel. One likely source of the confusion is the clip itself, which doesn’t correspond to the sounds humans generally make when they’re speaking.

Vowels and some consonants, like the those heard in “Laurel” and “Yanny,” have many frequencies when humans pronounce them through the vocal tract, Munson wrote, not unlike “hundreds of tuning forks playing at once.”

This is a spectrogram (a visual representation of those frequencies) of the “Laurel versus Yanny” meme. The dark bands represent what are known as “formants,” the frequencies that resonate the loudest. Vowels pronounced by humans have multiple formants, but the first two formants (F1 and F2) are crucial to determining what the vowel sounds like — such as whether you’re making an “eee” sound or an “ooo” sound.

Image

But zoom in on this clip and something is awry, Munson said:

Image

“Where there should be a second formant, there are just speckles that appear random,” he wrote. “One thing about this signal is that it’s hard to track the F2. This is perhaps the first ingredient into why it is so susceptible to being identified differently. The F2 is, for some reason (overlapping voices? Intentional shenanigans? The girl from The Ring?), masked.”

The clip’s fishiness doesn’t end there. Munson said if you zoom out again and take a look at the entire spectrogram, there’s something else going on. “You see some faint stripes that look like lighter-gray formants at those higher frequencies. Those shouldn’t be there,” he wrote. “Humans can’t produce those.”

Image

“I heard the higher-frequency formant sequences when I first listened to this signal two hours ago and thought that they maybe were someone talking in the background. Then I thought ERMERGERD, IT’S THE AUDIO VERSION OF THE RING,” Munson joked.

There isn’t actually another voice in there, he said. It’s just the lower-frequency patterns repeated at a higher frequency. Again, that mismatch — or “shenanigans,” as Munson called it — doesn’t happen with human speech.

Why this is going on in the Laurel/Yanny clip is less clear. “One possibility is that the formant pattern at the higher frequencies is just ‘Laurel’ transposed to higher frequencies, and that ‘Laurel’ sounds like [‘Yanny’] at higher frequencies,” Munson wrote. Another guess is that “Laurel” and “Yanny” got smashed together.

But all this confusion — those so-called “shenanigans” — forces our brains to fill in the blanks of how the clip should sound.

It’s possible that knowing there are two choices — “Laurel” and “Yanny” — preps us to hear one or the other distinctly. Or listeners could be affected by the language they speak, or the last thing they were listening to before they clicked on the meme.

These subtle, weird differences in how the human brain interprets sound is something scientists are constantly trying to better understand, Turnbull said. But for what it’s worth, he added, “this is a really cool auditory illusion.”


I hear Laurel, loud and clear, not ambiguous at all. I would never think anyone could hear anything else from that clip, especially not something so different as Yanny! Crazy stuff!
Using that slider tool I start hearing Yanny as soon as it's moved any amount to the right, but in the original audio it's Laurel every time.
Image
ToO Historian
ToO Historian
User avatar
bookworm

 
Posts: 14389
Joined: Thu Jul 06, 2006 8:10 pm
Location: reading or on the computer
Age: 27
Gender: Male

Cash on hand: 1,371.70
Bank: 56,000.00


Return to Finneman's Market

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: YandexBot and 3 guests