Mafia-Round Seven

[Jehoshaphat]

Astronomer's enthusiasm to kill Joy when KF actually said JCGJ and even voted for him check the votes. I believe that Astronomer and JCGJ and radgeek are Mafia please vote for them.
Vote:JCGJ

[Moontide]

I

vote: Whitty Whit.


because he acted weird and angery on page 2 and he no voted on page 5 after knight fisher explained why it was bad,

I am will to change my vote if someone else does something that is more suspicious.

Astronomer's enthusiasm to kill Joy when KF actually said JCGJ and even voted for him check the votes. I believe that Astronomer and JCGJ and radgeek are Mafia please vote for them.
Vote:JCGJ

Captain is not suspicious at this point. Joy is. There's no reason to waste this round on removing a new player, when we have a likely mafia. Bookworm, I know your intent with this was your general strategy. But now everyone is using as a cop out to blend in. Including the mafia.

[~JCGJ~]

JCGJ set up his chair, and watched as everyone gathered to discuss last night's kill.
"Well," he said, "I think we should vote for Joy. KF himself (the sherrif) said she was suspicious. I made a mistake in voting for Captain. I'll admit that. But I'm not going to make that mistake again. Therefor, I shall

Vote: Joy"

Astronomer's enthusiasm to kill Joy when KF actually said JCGJ and even voted for him check the votes.

"Yes, he voted for me, but then he un-voted, because it was my brother who made me look suspicious...
It seems like you're just looking for someone to accuse...
But anyway, I will tell you all right now; I am just a simple townie. I promise you that, while I may not be terribly valuble to the town, I am no harm to it."

[Joy]

The plan of "eliminating inexperienced players" has a flaw, and that is, if you eliminate a new and inexperienced player, the next time, they'll be just as inexperienced as last time. You aren't giving them a chance to prove themselves, and show that they're good at the game! You're eliminating someone blindly, not caring whether they're town or mafia, not knowing how good they may be. And that isn't good for townies. You could be eliminating someone with a very important role.
In my defense....I have none. I'm town, and that's all I can say. No fancy proof that I'm town, just a statement. That's all I can do.

[~JCGJ~]

The plan of "eliminating inexperienced players" has a flaw, and that is, if you eliminate a new and inexperienced player, the next time, they'll be just as inexperienced as last time. You aren't giving them a chance to prove themselves, and show that they're good at the game! You're eliminating someone blindly, not caring whether they're town or mafia, not knowing how good they may be. And that isn't good for townies. You could be eliminating someone with a very important role.
In my defense....I have none. I'm town, and that's all I can say. No fancy proof that I'm town, just a statement. That's all I can do.

"Yes, I agree with that whole-heartedly. Blind voting is rediculous (sp)..." JC raised his right hand, "I vow right now that I will not vote for someone, just because they are new... But Joy, I voted blindly last time, and I, in turn, killed Captain. I will not do that again. Because KF thought you were suspicious, I am inclined to believe him, because he was Sherrif."

[Joy]

The plan of "eliminating inexperienced players" has a flaw, and that is, if you eliminate a new and inexperienced player, the next time, they'll be just as inexperienced as last time. You aren't giving them a chance to prove themselves, and show that they're good at the game! You're eliminating someone blindly, not caring whether they're town or mafia, not knowing how good they may be. And that isn't good for townies. You could be eliminating someone with a very important role.
In my defense....I have none. I'm town, and that's all I can say. No fancy proof that I'm town, just a statement. That's all I can do.

"Yes, I agree with that whole-heartedly. Blind voting is rediculous (sp)..." JC raised his right hand, "I vow right now that I will not vote for someone, just because they are new... But Joy, I voted blindly last time, and I, in turn, killed Captain. I will not do that again. Because KF thought you were suspicious, I am inclined to believe him, because he was Sherrif."

I respect that, but if he knew, or investigated me, wouldn't he have said so? At least given more proof for me being guilty.

[Astronomer]

Astronomer glanced back and forth between JCGJ and Joy. "Uh, this is quite difficult, but I think I'll vote" *checks remaining players*
"Vote: Whitty Whit"

[~JCGJ~]

Astronomer's enthusiasm to kill Joy when KF actually said JCGJ and even voted for him check the votes. I believe that Astronomer and JCGJ and radgeek are Mafia please vote for them.
Vote:JCGJ

"Hey, I could also point out that you were fairly adament (sp) in voting for Joy as well..."

"I still think it is Joy. She is trying to shift the blame from her to Captain who I think is not the mafia. My vote stays.

I respect that, but if he knew, or investigated me, wouldn't he have said so? At least given more proof for me being guilty.

"...Joy, are you willing to put your integrity (sp) on the line, and pinky promise me that you are, indeed, just a townie?" JC looked Joy square in the eye. "If so, I will reconsider my vote."

[Jesus' Princess]

JP looked around, watching JC, Astronomer, and Joy go back and fourth. Based on the revelation the Knight Fisher was a sheriff, I think Joy does look suspicious. However, I won't vote just yet.

[Joy]

Jehoshaphat seems to be acting the most suspicious, blaming JCGJ out of the blue like that! Until I get further evidence, I'll vote:
Vote:Jehoshaphat

[Woody]

Joy, I'm sorry, but not responding to this:

"...Joy, are you willing to put your integrity (sp) on the line, and pinky promise me that you are, indeed, just a townie?" JC looked Joy square in the eye. "If so, I will reconsider my vote."

Makes you look very suspicious. At this point, I must

Vote: Joy

[Jehoshaphat]

I had forgotten about that JCGJ. Also Joy it was not "Voting out of the blue". Joy I still believe that you are guilty but I also believe that rad and Astronomer were a little to quick to put the blame on you. This round is confusing. I can honestly say that I am a townie.
Unvote: JCGJ
Vote: Joy

[Joy]

Joy looks at JCGJ. "I promise. I'm town, no doubt about it."

[~JCGJ~]

"Ok. I believe you. I really hope you're not lying to me. But I gave my word, so I'm reconsidering my vote." JC said. "After reviewing the past couple of pages, I have to say that Jehoshaphat is really shuffling blame around; trying to put the blame on anyone but himself.
Therefor, I must...


Unvote: Joy

Vote: Jehoshaphat"

[Joy]

"Ok. I believe you. I really hopre you're not lying to me. But I gave my word, so I'm reconsidering my vote." JC said. "After reviewing the past couple of pages, I have to say that Jehoshaphat is really shuffling blame around; trying to put the blame on anyone but himself.
Therefor, I must...

Vote: Jehoshaphat"

Well, at least someone believes me, somewhat.

[Aeva]

"You know, integrity isn't exactly the best defense you can provide in this game," Aeva said dryly. "Promises mean next to nothing when we're trying to find murderers. Any Mafia would lie through his or her teeth about being a townie." Aeva looked between Joy and JCGJ. "KF suspected you yesterday, Joy, as did I, although my suspicions were not as strong. Since it turns out that he was a Sheriff, I am now strongly inclined to vote for you. However, JCGJ, you are doing yourself no favors. Like I said, integrity and promises are essentially useless, and I wonder if you are professing integrity to make yourself seem innocent."

[Blitz]

Jehosaphat you are seeming most suspicious out of all that I have read.

Vote Jehosaphat

[Woody]

Joy looks at JCGJ. "I promise. I'm town, no doubt about it."

Sorry Joy, but my vote stands. Mostly because of you ignoring JC at first, but also because KF thought you were suspicious.

[~JCGJ~]

Joy, I'm sorry, but not responding to this:

"...Joy, are you willing to put your integrity (sp) on the line, and pinky promise me that you are, indeed, just a townie?" JC looked Joy square in the eye. "If so, I will reconsider my vote."

Makes you look very suspicious. At this point, I must

Vote: Joy

"Actually, I edited that post just as she was posting, so she didn't get a chance to look at it before she posted. You should learn to give people the benefit of the doubt... And to read when something was last edited."

"You know, integrity isn't exactly the best defense you can provide in this game," Aeva said dryly. "Promises mean next to nothing when we're trying to find murderers. Any Mafia would lie through his or her teeth about being a townie." Aeva looked between Joy and JCGJ. "KF suspected you yesterday, Joy, as did I, although my suspicions were not as strong. Since it turns out that he was a Sheriff, I am now strongly inclined to vote for you. However, JCGJ, you are doing yourself no favors. Like I said, integrity and promises are essentially useless, and I wonder if you are professing integrity to make yourself seem innocent."

"But I'm deciding to trust her word. If it turns out that she's lying, I will not trust her again for quite some time... But for now, I'm deciding to give her the benefit of the doubt."

[Woody]

Oh... Sorry. I don't usually pay attention to when things are edited.

Unvote: Joy
Vote: Jehoshaphat

Unless he can provide a good defense.