Page 1 of 8

Mafia Round 10 - MAFIA WON!!!!!!!!!

PostPosted: Wed Jan 30, 2013 10:10 pm
by Agent 86
It is now night.
Mafia send me your kill
Medic send me your save
Cop send me your investigation
Commuter if want to skip town send me a message saying
Example wrote:"I want to skip town"


Players:
Joy
Woody - Vengeful Townie
~JCGJ~ - Medic
bookworm - Dectective
Monty - Townie
Arkán Dreamwalker - Butch (Mafia)
Jesus' Princess
Tikvah
Bradley
Taps - Twin #1
Jehoshaphat
Killed by Mafia Lynched Removed

Good luck!

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 11:32 am
by Blitz
Le post I love doin this

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Day 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 12:51 pm
by Agent 86
Thanks Blitz!

Rodney Rathbone was wandering town doing mischief no doubt when he came to a house and thought, "I'll kill whoevers in this house and plunder the loot." so he had accompilces lift him up to the first floor and threw a dart at him/her thankfully that person was safe with the doc living at the house (The doc lost his home so him/her took him in under his/her wing)

Day 1

Fight and vote on who you think the Bones are :dark: !

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 2:22 pm
by ~JCGJ~
JC walked into the Town Hall, and wrote on a piece of paper (because no one was there yet),

"I am employing a new strategy this game. I will be experimenting with different options, just to see how they pan out.

Just to get the ball rolling here, I'm going to

Vote: Jehoshaphat.

Thank you,

~JCGJ~"

He taped the piece of paper to the front of the podium at the head of the room, then went to the corner to begin setting up his station.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 2:34 pm
by Joy
Joy walked slowly, a cloak covering her face. She ripped the hood away from her face, and gave a pompous gesture to the crowd. "Grrrreetingsss, all." She said rather grandly.
"It's the firrrst day, and the first moments of the first day. Although I'm surrrre your strrrrategy is grand, I may be able to learrrn some on this dayyyy." Joy trilled her words, making her sound airy and musical.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 2:52 pm
by Jesus' Princess
Jesus' Princess saw the gathering and walked over, after hearing the news of the close call that had taken place the night before, she looked around at her fellow town's people and wondered who among them was the Mafia.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 3:49 pm
by tahpahsoheJ
Whoa JC that vote made really no sense, explain your reasons or you are really being suspicious even guilty looking.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:08 pm
by ~JCGJ~
Jehoshaphat wrote:Whoa JC that vote made really no sense, explain your reasons or you are really being suspicious even guilty looking.

"I'm experimenting with something at the moment, and the best time to do that would be in the begninng of a new game, when I have no real leads."

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:20 pm
by bookworm
~JCGJ~ wrote:"I'm experimenting with something at the moment"
“With what? Casting unexplained votes? Everyone knows by now that’s a decidedly suspicious action. If it weren’t done during this first vote when one has an excuse to not have a basis for their vote, you would probably be a suspect right now.”

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:42 pm
by ~JCGJ~
bookworm wrote:
~JCGJ~ wrote:"I'm experimenting with something at the moment"
“With what? Casting unexplained votes? Everyone knows by now that’s a decidedly suspicious action. If it weren’t done during this first vote when one has an excuse to not have a basis for their vote, you would probably be a suspect right now.”

"Which is exactly why I'm doing it in the beginning, when there's really no basis for anyone's votes. I might tell you my strategy once the game is done (unless, of course, it actually works, and then I'll just keep it to myself. :P ). I don't want to disrupt the results of my experiment by disclosing the information too soon, which could possibly change people's strategies, and muck up my observations... I'm simply using this game to try out some new techniques for future games. It's really not as complicated as I'm making it out to be. It's a rather simple experiment, and if the results go according to my hypothesis, it may work fairly well in future games as well.
I will tell you this though: the vote choice itself was indeed random. It was simply the reasoning behind it that was not, if that makes any sense at all."

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:53 pm
by Taps
This is very interesting... on one hand voting is almost always blind on the first day, but I don't know if we should jump to accusations so quickly, even if you are in the process of an experiment...

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 4:56 pm
by bookworm
~JCGJ~ wrote:the vote choice itself was indeed random. It was simply the reasoning behind it that was not, if that makes any sense at all.
“It makes sense in that I know what you mean, but didn’t we just go over why random voting is a bad idea? ](*,)

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 5:31 pm
by Arkán Dreamwalker
I think I know what JC is doing. And I must say, Tron's writing abilities leave something to be desired.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 6:00 pm
by ~JCGJ~
bookworm wrote:
~JCGJ~ wrote:the vote choice itself was indeed random. It was simply the reasoning behind it that was not, if that makes any sense at all.
“It makes sense in that I know what you mean, but didn’t we just go over why random voting is a bad idea? ](*,)

"I often have a hard time following you, because you say "Random voting is bad!" and then you say, "But it's better to random vote than to not vote at all" and then when someone does vote randomly, it's deemed as suspicious by you, even when it's on the first day, and the only thing that really makes sense is a random vote..."

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 6:05 pm
by bookworm
~JCGJ~ wrote:you say "Random voting is bad!" and then you say, "But it's better to random vote than to not vote at all
“Which are both true statements and not contradictory. I wouldn’t think I would need to explain this, but the order of best-for-the-Town votes are as follows, from best to worst:
Sure vote
Well informed vote
Based vote
Baseless vote
Random vote
No vote

~JCGJ~ wrote:then when someone does vote randomly, it's deemed as suspicious by you, even when it's on the first day, and the only thing that really makes sense is a random vote...
No, not when it’s on the first day. This random vote is not a problem, because there’s nothing else to go on. But you make it seem as though this mysterious ‘strategy’ you’re trying to develop is based on random voting. (Because it seemed as if the focus was on who you voted for, but you then said the vote was random.)”

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 6:08 pm
by tahpahsoheJ
Bookworms long lasting strategy is to remove inactive players randomly not chose an active player randomly. I deem voting on your very first post of the game ishighly suspicious.

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 6:14 pm
by bookworm
Jehoshaphat wrote:Bookworms long lasting strategy is to remove inactive players
“Which on the list I just made, if anyone is curious, is a based vote. Not the best, but at least it has some motivation behind it.”

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 7:37 pm
by ~JCGJ~
Jehoshaphat wrote:Bookworms long lasting strategy is to remove inactive players randomly not chose an active player randomly. I deem voting on your very first post of the game ishighly suspicious.

"So you want me to come in and say, "JC sat down and set up his station etc. etc. etc." and provide nothing to the conversation, and then come in later and vote after someone else decides to post? That would be less suspicious? I think that's just a waste of time."

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 7:38 pm
by Agent 86
You have 41 hours to vote....

Arkán Dreamwalker wrote:Tron's writing abilities leave something to be desired.

:x

Re: Mafia Round 10 - Night 1

PostPosted: Fri Feb 01, 2013 7:41 pm
by Monty
Monty strolled up, listening all the while.

"Meh, sure voting on your first post can be suspicious, but it can be done. See?"

VOTE: JCGJ

Reasons:

1. He made an admittedly baseless, random vote on the first day.

2. He indicated that he plans to continue with this random voting throughout the game.

I must say, the second reason worries me significantly more than first. If he is Town, then it would be best to eliminate someone who is going to distract us from finding actual Mafia for the rest of the game. If he is Mafia, then he not only urgently needs to be eliminated now, but he can play off legitimate votes for people that the Mafia knows as threats as supposedly random votes.

Let me say as well, to anyone that disputes my decision, that I am not set in this decision. This is the decision I have made based on what has already been posted, and will stay my decision until quite possibly the very next post. Town, let's make sure to focus on logic and reasons for voting in this game.

Also, I would like to point out at this time that we did have a Medic save last night. This save could have been bookworm, it could have been JCGJ, it could have been me, it could have been anyone. Nevertheless, this has cleared up in my mind one person who I do not believe is Mafia.